Okay, so the rules are scamming is legal. Yes Hearts lead the gang for a long time, but the rules are the rules. In real life if somebody shot someone, but said they did it because the person was aggravating them, would the rules change? No. It was her own fault, and nothing should change, if you give it back, then how is that fair to the players who get scammed constantly? Shouldn't they just be able to get refunds? Even though it's a big gang it isn't different at all. She gave it to him, and it's his decision what he wants to do with it. And you people saying it's breaking the rules not giving it back to her, are just plain retarded. It may be immoral what was done, but that doesn't change anything. Layerd knows that, and I'll even tell him that myself. You can't let one player get a second chance or everyone should get a second chance. You won't get your gang back, and if you do, then everyone else who has ever been scammed of anything should be refunded.
If you allow this staff you're opening a new door, and I know you don't want that door open. Hearts for the good of the server count your losses and move on, your gang isn't as important as the server, you're pathetic if you think it is.