Why I've always been against 'popular' people being hired/ people who still actively play and have potential bias.

If you are prepared to become a staff member then you have to be prepared to potentially jail your 'friends' if they are doing something wrong. Can't do that then don't apply.

If there were other staff there who told someone who hadn't witnessed anything to punish that person then they are also at fault.
Doesn't make sense to tell someone who didn't see the crime happened to take action on it, and it doesn't make sense for that person to agree to it. Either there is lying going on or they are all biased against asirader/ towards the Jay person